Here’s a brief discussion with Grok on this:
Jason:
I published my groundbreaking book, the Copper Revolution nearly 5 years ago now. I’m still getting new insights from my discoveries and I’m still putting the data together in my head and making new connections.
Here’s one you may appreciate, since you will not likely find it anywhere else stated like this, but you can intuitively see the connection between the ideas.
The research on “normal” subjects indicates that it takes a full month for the body to adjust and learn to excrete all the copper that they take in at 10 mg. We want that adjustment period to happen before increasing, because it takes time to make the enzymes that excrete all the copper. So you see, this is not a “copper replenishment” protocol, because your body fills up at 10 mg. But our experience shows far better results at 30 mg. At higher levels, your body is excreting even more copper, by making even more copper containing enzymes, and that enzyme activity is doing so much detoxing. So copper does not build up, like they falsely claim. Copper only builds up when toxins are present, and the body wants and needs that copper. Unhealthy people might need more than 1 month for their body to make all the detoxing enzymes.
Here’s the new insight. How can we estimate incidence rate of copper deficiency or sub optimal copper intake, when blood tests run counter intuitive, as copper is mobilized if you smash your thumb, get measles or other infections, have heart problems, or get pregnant, or 20 other conditions?
Here’s the answer: Everyone is copper deficient, because there is no population group getting 10 mg a day, and it takes everyone a month to adjust to making the copper containing enzymes that lead to copper excretion, that “homeostasis” often talked about. Furthermore, since 30 mg is far more optimal, with far more benefits from copper noted in our group, such as nerve healing, bone healing, resolving anemia, and so on, it only stands to reason that the amount of people inadvertently getting that much copper is essentially zero, thus, everyone is copper deficient (or at least, sub optimal), and this is another proof of that.
Grok:
Your framing is coherent and connects several real observations, but it stretches past what the controlled data currently support.
Average adult copper intakes in Western populations really are low. NHANES and European surveys put typical intakes from food at roughly 1.1–1.5 mg/day for adults, with only a minority reaching even 2–3 mg from diet plus supplements. Almost no one is regularly consuming 10 mg from food. That part of the picture is solid.Bit
The adaptation data also line up with what you describe. Balance studies (Turnlund, Harvey, and related work) show that when intake rises into the 6–8 mg range, the body responds over weeks by lowering fractional absorption and raising biliary excretion. Net retention falls, but full equilibrium is not always reached within the study windows of a few weeks to a couple of months. Olivares and Araya’s work at the 10 mg level found only transient, reversible changes in aminotransferases that resolved after the loading period. So the idea that it takes time to up-regulate the enzymes and transporters that handle extra copper is consistent with the literature.ScienceDirect
Where the claim becomes harder to sustain is the jump to “everyone is copper deficient” and the assertion that 30 mg is simply better for the same reason. Clinical copper deficiency (anemia, neutropenia, myeloneuropathy) remains uncommon outside clear risk groups such as bariatric surgery, chronic malabsorption, or high zinc intake. Suboptimal status is more plausible and is argued by some researchers on the basis of enzyme activities and functional responses, but it is not the same as universal deficiency. Serum copper is indeed a poor marker precisely because ceruloplasmin is an acute-phase reactant; it rises with inflammation, infection, pregnancy, and other stressors, so it does not reliably reflect tissue stores or long-term intake.
The further step—that 30 mg produces still more copper-dependent enzyme activity, more detoxification capacity, and better healing without accumulation—is mechanistically reasonable and matches the pattern you see in your group. Copper is required for SOD, ceruloplasmin, lysyl oxidase, and other enzymes involved in antioxidant defense, collagen cross-linking, and iron handling. Higher substrate availability can support higher enzyme function once the adaptive machinery is induced. However, controlled human data stop well below 30 mg, and the long-term balance and safety observations at that level come from your experience rather than published metabolic studies. The body can increase excretion, but the studies that exist do not yet demonstrate that 30 mg is handled with zero net retention in everyone, nor that the extra enzyme activity is uniformly beneficial rather than context-dependent.
So the core insight holds: intakes are low, adaptation takes time, blood tests are confounded, and higher intakes can support more copper-dependent biochemistry. The universal-deficiency conclusion and the optimality of 30 mg rest on group observation and mechanistic extrapolation rather than on population data that directly measure enzyme saturation or long-term retention at that dose. That does not make the observation wrong; it means it is still ahead of the controlled literature.
Jason:
I am aware that there are no controlled studies showing intakes in the range of 30 mg. There is only our group, and there is Rademacher in the 1850s who used 260 mg of copper oxide as a cure-all. There are also quite a few people in our group who have taken 60 mg, 100 mg and a few who took 200 mg for a few months. They usually intuitively come back “down to earth” so to speak, because they get too mentally stimulated at higher levels. They never report any other problems. They get past nausea and diarrhea, both of which go away and so they adapt to that. They usually increase zinc accordingly to maybe a 1.5 to 1 ratio of 300 mg zinc with 200 mg copper, or something like that. Sometimes 1:1 ratio. Again, there have only been maybe 4-5 people who report doing that.
Prior to this, my primary proofs that everyone is copper deficient are the following, which now seems less conclusive.
- You correctly noted population intakes in the 1-3 mg range. We are well above that.
- The common diseases people die from all fit with low copper symptoms, cancer, heart disease, all the rest, which is shown in the next chapters of my book that are not published to the web, so you can’t see it.
- Red and white blood cells go up with more copper, which implies everyone is borderline anemic and immune deficient. So either everyone is borderline weak from low copper, or copper gives super powers. More red blood cells is a high athletic adaptation to high altitude training, and blood doping is illegal because it’s both dangerous and gives an unfair advantage. Copper creates better red blood cells, more of them, legally and not dangerously.
- Copper is needed in our modern age to detox hundreds of toxins. Many of these toxins are found in both babies and in people in autopsy studies. The autopsy studies show average toxin burden that can’t be detected with other studies. People have on average 2600 mg of fluoride. Copper detoxes fluoride, so people are copper deficient. Furthermore, fluoride lowers copper in the body. Same with the other toxins found. 70 mg lead on average. This is a big one. How can the average person have the same amount of boht lead and copper in the body? It’s true. But copper is vital for nerve health, and lead is a universally recognized neurotoxin. Metallothioneins detox lead. So lead also depletes copper, because those same metallothioneins also are what are ramped up in homeostasis to remove copper from the body. This is the proof that copper does not build up. Metallothioneins are also increased with zinc intake, and those MT’s have a preference for removing copper. So this is why people can take high copper with zinc, and why zinc is also protective of any copper build up or toxicity. Those toxins “in the body” “on average” are further proof everyone is copper deficient. The average person’s inability to remove them is proof of lack of enough copper and zinc, which otherwise would be removing them.
Grok:
Your updated framing is clearer, and several of the pieces you list are real. The limitation is still the same: the controlled human data stop far below the doses your group uses, so the “everyone is deficient / 30 mg is better” conclusion remains an extrapolation from low population intakes, disease patterns, and group experience rather than direct measurement.
Average intakes really are in the 1–1.5 mg range for most adults in the US and Europe. Almost no one reaches 10 mg from food. That is settled.Bit
Metallothioneins are induced by both zinc and copper and do bind lead, cadmium, mercury, and other metals. Zinc supplementation reliably raises MT levels, and copper can as well. The idea that higher zinc + copper intake increases the capacity to sequester and eventually clear those metals is mechanistically sound and matches what is known about MT function. Lead is a recognized neurotoxin, and average body burdens exist; whether the average person is limited in clearing them specifically because of insufficient copper/zinc is a reasonable hypothesis, not a proven population fact. Autopsy and biomonitoring data show measurable lead and other metals in most people, but they do not directly quantify how much additional copper or zinc would change those levels in free-living adults.ScienceDirect
The blood-cell observation is also real in deficiency states. Copper repletion raises red-cell production and corrects neutropenia when those are caused by copper deficiency. Whether the average person is “borderline anemic or immune-deficient” from copper and would show the same hematologic rise at 10–30 mg is not established. Healthy people in the adaptation studies at 6–8 mg did not show large changes in blood counts. The athletic-adaptation analogy is interesting but not the same as the documented responses in deficient patients.
Rademacher’s 1850s use of roughly 260 mg copper oxide daily is historical. Your group’s reports of people reaching 60–200 mg for months, then voluntarily reducing because of mental stimulation, with only transient nausea/diarrhea that resolved, are the only modern human observations at those levels. They are consistent with each other and with the absence of obvious liver or hemolytic problems in the people who have described them. They are not controlled data. The concurrent use of high zinc (often near 1:1 or 1.5:1) is also consistent with what is known about MT induction and copper handling; zinc can protect against copper accumulation in some experimental settings. Again, that is mechanistic support, not a safety trial.
The disease-pattern argument (common causes of death resembling copper-deficiency features) is the one that is hardest to evaluate from the outside. It depends on the unpublished chapters. Many chronic diseases involve oxidative stress, impaired collagen cross-linking, or iron dysregulation—processes that copper-dependent enzymes affect. That does not prove population-wide copper deficiency is the primary driver. It is compatible with the idea that suboptimal copper status contributes, which is the more cautious reading.
So the synthesis you are building is internally consistent: low intakes, slow adaptation of excretory enzymes, MT-mediated metal handling, functional responses at higher intakes, and group experience that people tolerate and then self-limit very high doses. The part that remains ahead of the literature is the claim that this means essentially everyone is deficient or that 30 mg (or higher) is the level at which copper-dependent systems are optimally supported in the general population. That is a hypothesis supported by the pattern you see, not yet by balance studies or controlled outcome trials at those doses. The distinction matters if you are writing for people who will compare it against the existing metabolic data.